Connect with us

Chris' Commentary

Opinion: Wolf Administration Asking Schools to Violate Constitution by Upholding Gather Limits

Photo by Kim Constantino

The Wolf Administration is at it again and this time it is brazen.

In asking local school districts to “voluntarily” enforce the 25-person indoor limit and a 250-person outdoor limit on fans, it is currently asking school districts to violate the United States Constitution.

Regardless of how you, me, Governor Wolf, or anyone else feels about the limits, which were put in place to mitigate the spread of COVID-19, a federal judge, William Strickman IV, on Monday, Sept. 14, ruled those measures to be unconstitutional.

The Wolf administration is appealing that decision and has asked the judge for a stay of his order, which as of 3 p.m. Friday, Sept. 18, had not been issued.

That means that as of Friday afternoon, in my opinion – and I couch that by saying while I have a degree in Political Science and have studied some constitutional law I am not a lawyer – it is literally unconstitutional for schools to place a limit – below capacity restrictions – on fans attending sporting events.

The Wolf administration knows this. That is why they aren’t enforcing the limit at this point. But what they are doing is knowingly asking schools to enforce it and in the process violate the Constitution of the United States.

Is the Wolf administration willing to pay for the legal bills these schools are going to incur when they are sued for the same constitutional violation the Wolf administration was found in violation of Monday?

Until Strickman’s ruling is overturned by a higher court or he orders a stay of his order it is unconstitutional for a government entity, which a public school district is, to limit gatherings below capacity restrictions.

To ask schools to violate Strickman is beyond brazen and is a full out attack on the rule of law by the Wolf administration. You can’t ask people to violate the law just because you don’t like the law. But that is what the Wolf administration is doing plain and simple to school districts.

Mark my word, if schools enforce this recommendation, they will be sued.

The best bet for school districts is until a stay is ordered or until an appellate court overturns Strickman’s decision, they would wise to allow fans in their stadiums/gyms within capacity restrictions. Otherwise, they could be paying for it later.

More in Chris' Commentary